Buy MTG Cards | Buy Magic the Gathering Cards Online at the Wizards Cupboard (2025)

FAQs

Do pawn shops buy Magic The Gathering cards? ›

But like collectibles stores, pawn shops price their items to sell fast, so they will most likely offer you less money for your Magic Cards than anywhere else. It is a quick and all-cash transaction though.

Buy From Store

Buying sealed products, tickets, and bundles from the store is a straightforward way to start your collection. To do this, go to the Store Tab inside the MTGO Client, select the product of your liking, and add it to your cart. Most of the time, there's no limit on how many you can buy.

You can typically expect around 70% market value in cash for the cards and 10% to 15% more for store credit. If you can't get to an LGS or they don't want to buy your cards, you can also sell them directly to sites like Star City Games or Card Kingdom.

A rare Magic: The Gathering card has sold for $3 million, making it the most expensive Magic card ever sold. And before you ask, Magic nerds, of course it was a Black Lotus. The sale of the card was announced last week by CGC Cards, a certification and grading company for trading cards, video games, comics, and more.

A red-orange symbol indicates the card is mythic rare. A gold symbol indicates the card is rare. A silver symbol indicates the card is uncommon. A black or white symbol indicates the card is common or is a basic land.

Magic Online includes an innovative feature that allows players to redeem a complete set of digital cards for a complete set of physical cards, which will then be shipped to the address associated with the Magic Online account.

Every Magic Online account comes with 800 free cards, which includes 40 of each basic land (Forest, Island, Mountain, Plains, Swamp), 2 of each Common from the five most recent sets (currently Kaladesh, Aether Revolt, Amonkhet, Hour of Devastation, and Ixalan), and several other Uncommons, and Rares.

Selling your collection on MTGO is allowed. Selling your account on MTGO is not allowed. This is an important distinction, and you should be clear as the seller than you are only selling the items in your collection and not your account itself.

The rarity of a Magic card can have a significant impact on its value. Generally, the rarer a card is, the more valuable it is likely to be. There are four levels of rarity in Magic: The Gathering: common, uncommon, rare, and mythic rare. Mythic rare cards are the rarest and most valuable.

Magic: The Gathering fans are upset with how much product Hasbro has been releasing. Hasbro's strategy has put a strain on fans' wallets, who feel they have to buy the cards to keep up. Some game shop owners have had to sell cards at a lower cost — meaning they lose money and Magic loses value.

What is the app that tells you how much Magic cards are worth? ›

Scan a card with the CardCastle app to instantly price check it! Know how much your cards are worth and track the value of your collection over time to make better buying, selling and trading decisions.

The rarity of a Magic card can have a significant impact on its value. Generally, the rarer a card is, the more valuable it is likely to be. There are four levels of rarity in Magic: The Gathering: common, uncommon, rare, and mythic rare. Mythic rare cards are the rarest and most valuable.

Though unplayable in most formats, Black Lotus has been remixed into slightly different cards with similar powers but with better balance. The record-breaking $3 million Black Lotus was graded by CGC Cards and rated as a 10, or in “pristine” condition, making it the highest quality Black Lotus card ever sold.

Splash in enough rares and mythics into the commons bulk box to increase how much you can safely charge to a buyer to make it more worthwhile. Otherwise, selling a box of just commons and uncommons can yield you about $5 to $10 per 1,000 cards.